Showing posts with label smoke. Show all posts
Showing posts with label smoke. Show all posts

Friday, February 10, 2012

Charcoal, wood and cook-stoves- best fit for Maasai women?

Undoubtedly charcoal burning is a major problem across the semi arid and arid lands. The destruction of trees and vegetation leads to erosion, land degradation and a reduced water table, decreasing grazing land and increasing the cycle of poverty.   Without a licence of course it is illegal to burn charcoal but the only people with a vested interest in enforcing this are the landowners themselves. The local Group Ranches that are involved in conservation all have a good understanding that charcoal burning is not in their interests. The picture shows a charcoal operation carried out by local Chiefs and Ol Lentille rangers, with the backing of the police, to confiscate sacks of illegal charcoal. Such operations have to be ongoing to keep on top of the problem, and these operations need excellent organisation to be successful and are expensive to perform. The vast majority of illegal  charcoal is sent out on trucks to towns where the money obtained is ten times what is given to the local charcoal burner. 
Some charcoal is sold locally and used by ‘wealthier’ women on cook-stoves, where it is more efficient and less smoky than the traditional open wood fires.  These women will be those  in employment who  have less time to collect wood. In the last few months there has been something of a technology shift: the price of charcoal has rocketed and women are finding it harder to purchase. The wealthiest of these women are now buying 6kg gas cylinders and the trucks coming up to the two weekly market are bringing refills. So far the number of women buying is very small, but this seems to be something very much market driven and, with access to small ‘development’ loans from the local micro-finance project odds are on that 2012 -13 will see a larger shift. All forms of development are, for better or worse, aspirational: the more women who have these gas stoves the more will want one.
Still, this is going to be well outside the budget for poorer families- especially since it is likely to be these families with more children and greater fuel needs.
We have been working over the last year with selling subsidised low smoke stoves to households. But undoubtedly there are very real challenges with the current stove designs. Still too much wood is required for the busiest employed women and the stoves are too slow to get hot. For each mealtime or tea time the cook-stove has to be re lit- whereas the traditional open fire will stay hot all day, and adding another piece of wood and a pan is a quick process . In addition the stoves are too small to cook meals for the larger family sizes. Additionally the stoves give off a fair amount of smoke whilst lighting- leading many ladies to consider that the health benefits we are so keen on touting ‘less smoke- less smoke’... are not quite realistic.
So for those families who are unlikely to be moving to the gas generation any time soon we are looking for some ways forward.
Taking lessons from the pit latrine building programme – behaviour can be adapted only when the benefits can be clearly seen. And of course then there is the critical mass phenomenon - once enough latrines have been erected the ball takes on its own momentum. But the fit has to be the right one. Our health campaign work  badly needs to help enable  women to find less smoky cooking solutions. The younger educated women know this and are concerned but the design of the stove has to be the right fit for the community. Only when the younger women have a stove design they can work well with will the older women jump onto the bandwagon too.

Sunday, November 20, 2011

Clean Cookstoves... Save Trees.. Save Lives

As a follow up to the May 17th blog, this blog is certainly somewhat overdue! With the huge support of Paradigm Stoves , we now have Institutional Stoves working in 9 schools, plus our own Staff Kitchen. This donation has been a resounding success, and no unintended consequences have so far been thrown up. The implementation of the project was bigger than either we, or Paradigm, could have imagined. In the first instance the smaller nursery schools had no kitchens... so step one was to erect simple secure, weather proof, structures.. only not so simple when we realised that we would have to make new roads to Rumate and Singa'un nurseries, before we had any hope of getting materials and stoves to them! Finding a route through the luggas, rocks and dense bush to Singa'un required a day on foot feeling rather Dr. Livingstone'ish, before we could hope to get a pick up through. The huge added advantage of this is that now we have a road that the mobile clinic can traverse once a month to this remote Samburu village. How people survive in this location in the dry season beggars belief.. the trip for water is a 6 hour round trip with donkeys that each household has to perform every two days.
Below is the new kitchen at Narasha Nursery school-




These stoves use a very minimal amount of wood... where children were collecting wood on a daily basis this is now reduced to once or twice per month. Paradigm also provided a training for all the school cooks who have been universally thrilled with the stoves.. where we could have foreseen some resistance to 'new' technology the benefits are all self evident.. virtually no smoke , much quicker cooking times and , an unforeseen benefit of much easier cleaning has led not only to happy cooks but also to a real pride in the cleanliness of the kitchens.



In addition we have given away 80 household stoves to the Ol Lentille employees, Conservancy Rangers and and Health Workers, and have sold another 100 at subsidised prices. We still have some 40 more to sell. This area of the donation has been enormously interesting- (if at times somewhat challenging!) showing how much research we still need to do to work with communities on the best fit of stove for them. Communities being made up of individuals, of course means that no one solution fits all: age , gender, education levels, family size, are just some of the variables we need to consider. This is still very much a work in progress that we will come back to as we collate our results...